automatically put her in cuffs and walk her out automatically put her in cuffs and walk her right out I just wanted to go home okay I don't want no problem I don't want no problem alright hang out with her until I do my PC automatically put her in cuffs and walk her out automatically put her in cuffs and walk her right out man I don't have any I can't put them on now what's the matter arms up he be racist he keep me off the plane okay alright he be racist alright give me a minute they kicked me out the play turn around yes turn around this is for my my safety and yours put your hand behind your back ma'am come on let's go sit over here come sit over here ma'am come sit over here no ma'am I'm listening to you okay we're gonna come sit have a seat have a seat have a seat but don't be racist and kick me off a plane they can kick me off a plane over nothing I wasn't doing nothing ask all of them I wasn't doing nothing but it's too late for that now alright I don't care I wasn't doing nothing it's still racism call racism what racism is alright man I don't love too many friends this racist *ss sh*t I love too many friends this wh*te *ss people sh*t ma'am I need to ask you a question are you on any medication or no test me no no no no no we're trying to find out if you have something medical going on no ma'am they picked on me and I'm hurt how much have you had to drink today uh I had about two double shots and uh two seltzers OK well ma'am what's your name that's OK double soda double shot listen I don't have any gloves on can you wipe the hair out of my mouth that's not true I was gonna say go back you told me okay you gave me out of the way listen to me listen to me it told me listen to me listen to me it was in my bed we're gonna get your ID listen to me now I just wanted to go home okay I don't want no problem I don't want no problem alright but now listen to me listen to me I wanna ask you something you told Deputy Shoemaker that you had two drinks two shots right I did maybe that's probably why I was sitting down being quiet and they came to me and picked on me well did nobody else say sh*t but them I was not saying nothing about I was just sitting there being quiet trying to go home but now it's too late for that but they gonna pick on me cause I know that love is love OK because I'm not racist they gonna pick on me it's alright relax yeah I'm getting loud'cause I got a problem with racism I got a big *ss problem with racism I only care just take me to prison I only care just tell me that because I don't submit that you f*cking black is different than white'cause I ain't gonna ever submit hey yo y'all be a racist I don't care I don't even care I don't even care I didn't do no wrong I didn't do no wrong on October 6th 2,022 Broward County Sheriff's Office deputies responded to a disturbance at Fort Lauderdale Hollywood International Airport the footage was captured on an Axon Body 3 camera and documents an arrest involving a female passenger removed from an aircraft prior to this recording within the first 15 seconds of footage an officer states the intent to immediately handcuff the subject before any direct contact has been made this is constitutionally significant The Fourth Amendment requires probable cause before a lawful arrest can be executed a preformed intent to arrest stated before assessing current conditions and creates legal vulnerability regardless of what prior events may have established under Terry v Ohio 392 United States 1 officers must evaluate circumstances at the moment of contact not act on decisions made in advance I didn't do no wrong no y'all be racist y'all have to be sitting up bro Chelsea we're gonna go down to the plane for nothing I'm we're gonna go Chelsea go home I'm sorry now put your shoes on so Chelsea Chelsea Chelsea put your shoes on put your shoes on what up you got all the rest of our bags yeah that's it that's it those aren't hers they don't keep me off the plane for nothing bro cause I know love is love alright why in the f*ck they don't keep me off the plane cause I why in the f*ck your wh*te *ss b*tch there are children here I don't care f*ck you and your wh*te *ss b*tches white man too I promise to god wh*te *ss it's your wh*te *ss *ss wh*te *ss place you ain't white enough no I ain't white enough racism f*ck your racism lock me up I don't care if you let me out lock me up you racist *ss racist *ss mother f*cker I don't give a mother f*ck I'm just trying to fly home and do right ask me I don't give a f*ck about those racist *ss mother I submit to this sh*t yo y'all pick on a white b*tch try to fly home and go to prison pick on me pick on me and I'm drunk enough to put up with y'all sh*t OK pick on me OK OK pick on me I don't give a I promise to god get them we don't need them I'll give up you wh*te *ss motherf*ckers you wh*te *ss motherf*ckers let's go let's go oh let's pick on her cause she tried to go to prison let's pick on her she tried to send her *ss back to prison I don't give a f*ck that's racist *ss that's racist *ss motherf*cker I'm trying to fly home and go to prison y'all try to hate on somebody cause if it ain't one year no no push push push you racist you just no no no no don't do that don't do that don't do it you just racist don't bite me you are just racist push that's not what I meant oh my sister easy ah yeah I know I'm not I'm not you're racist as a motherf*cker I was trying to go home I'm alright I'm alright where's the door right here right here these doors you can't go out these doors no no go to the other door alright oh yes trust the car you're a racist we're gonna have to racist *ss motherf*cker let the alarm go off go ahead open the door I got the door I know there we go the subject makes sustained profane statements directed at officers throughout the encounter the threshold question is whether this speech is protected or criminal The Supreme Court in city of Houston versus Hill 482 United States 4 51 held that profane or offensive language directed at police is protected First Amendment expression absent a direct threat of violence mere offensiveness does not constitute criminal conduct officers cannot arrest in a subject solely because the language is hostile or embarrassing to law enforcement however the First Amendment analysis does not end there Florida Statute Section 8 77.03 prohibits conduct that constitutes an actual breach of the peace not merely offensive speech sustained high volume disruption in a crowded international terminal where families with children are present moves the conduct closer to the actionable threshold than an isolated verbal insult would Florida courts have upheld disorderly conduct charges where the totality of conduct volume duration environment and audience collectively breached the peace even when individual statements were protected the subject self reported consuming two double shots and two seltzers before the incident this disclosure combined with observable behavior independently establishes probable cause under Florida Statute Section 8 56.0 11 disorderly intoxication requires both intoxication in a public space and conduct that endangers safety or causes a public disturbance both elements are met here during processing the subject moves toward a restricted exit in the terminal this is not a minor detail under 49 United States Code Section 46 3 14 unauthorized access to restricted airport areas is a federal offense officers correctly redirected the subject without escalating to higher force which reflects proportionate tactical judgment consistent with department protocol racist *ss motherf*cker I know I know racist *ss motherf*cker okay I didn't do that wrong I didn't do that wrong I didn't do anything I just want to go home please give me my bubbles please please give me my bubbles please I'm not fine I'm not fine I'm not fine I'm not fine I'm not fine I'm not fine I'm not fine all force applied in this encounter must be evaluated under Graham versus Conner 490 United States 3 86 reasonableness is judged from the perspective of a reasonable officer on the scene not with hindsight the 3 g factors are severity of the crime at issue whether the subject poses an immediate safety threat and whether the subject is actively resisting applied here the crimes at issue are misdemeanors the subject posed no weapon threat resistance was active but nonviolent force limited to physical control and handcuffing satisfies the proportionality requirement during processing the subject attempts to dislodge an officer's body camera this constitutes resisting without violence under Florida Statute Section 8 43.02 a first degree misdemeanor the statute requires resistance during the lawful execution of a legal duty if the underlying detention is lawful which the alcohol admission and disorderly conduct support then this resistance is independently chargeable officers issue a directive to double lock the handcuffs this is standard arrest procedure required to prevent the restraints from tightening and causing injury a detail that reflects proper training the welfare inquiry asking whether the subject was on medication is consistent with crisis intervention training and Florida's Baker Act framework which permits involuntary examination when a person appears mentally ill and presents a danger stand up yes sir OK OK alright stand up stand up don't you we're not gonna do that stand up no double lock it I'm sorry double lock it what's your name Jessie Jessie yeah can you stand up yes thank you alright oh Jesus over there where here right here OK that's hard I know hey stop it before we go in yeah Sandy come back here no we can't take those off now no no no I'm not a racist hey lift up your right leg Cassidy lift up your right leg put it up we believe you lift up your left leg I won't be here I'm not racist you gotta do me like this OK please give me my bubbles in my juicy book hold on officer my juicy book my juicy bag you got it you got it we got everything we got your bag where's my juice bag show it okay we'll show it to you alright how much you had to drink no no you don't what OK OK OK OK OK OK oh no no you don't what let go of me no no no you don't break my camera f*cking *ss my camera that's all right I have a seat have a seat I'm sorry have a seat I will let me go I did not go in I do nothing wrong sit up sit up I just wanna go home I do nothing wrong you'll get the opportunity to go home as soon as we get done get up sit up get up in the chair sit up sit on the chair I do nothing wrong there we go I do nothing wrong but not I agree with racism and y'all go pick on me I do nothing wrong I didn't do nothing wrong what goes what happens wait a minute huh I gotta get all her information you find ID I'm downstairs though so n*gga hey hang out with her until I do my PC I'm sure yeah and then we're gonna put it back in your car hell nah I'm gonna follow you to the I'm gonna follow these n*ggas to the main jail I'm gonna see you little alpha yank me too OK that's gonna be a sub for everybody get my car bring it up this wasn't improvised let's examine what the law authorizes and what it doesn't an officer near the end of the footage references needing to document probable cause before completing transport this on camera acknowledgement of the PC threshold is legally significant it reflects awareness of the constitutional requirement a civil rights claim under 42 United States Code Section 1983 would face significant challenges here given the subject's documented physical resistance and the officer's measured proportionate response throughout the responding deputy receives a C plus force was proportionate and composure was maintained under sustained provocation however the preformed arrest intent stated before subject contact creates a Fourth Amendment vulnerability that undermines an otherwise sound tactical performance the subject receives a d plus the underlying grievance may have been genuine but the response sustained disruption physical resistance and self incriminating statements eliminated legal defenses that silence and compliance would have preserved Broward County Sheriff's Office receives a B minus officers demonstrated adequate training in de escalation and proportionate force the gap is the absence of clearly documented probable cause articulation at scene initiation the controlling lesson from this encounter is sequencing probable cause must be assessed and documented at the point of contact not assumed from prior events and not preannounced before evaluation occurs for the subject the right to protest a perceived injustice exists but it does not extend to physical resistance restricted area access or prolonged public disruption the appropriate remedy was a formal complaint not a confrontation in a terminal in airport environments the stakes are elevated federal jurisdiction overlaps with state authority restricted area violations carry federal exposure and the captive audience of a terminal applies a lower threshold for what constitutes a breach of the peace let us know if there is an interaction or legal topic that you would like us to discuss in the comments below thank you for watching and don't forget to subscribe to our channel for more content on police court interactions