one of the nearest trash cans you guys have your IDS with you do not resist me or you're going to the ground the driver's license number that's on that it's a fake ID she's like 24 okay well your friend has a terrible fake ID location Volusia County Florida Incident beach patrol contact involving underage alcohol possession fraudulent identification presented to law enforcement date of footage not not specified in available records hello hey there's no alcohol out on the beach oh I'm sorry uh where can I talk to you about uh at one of the nearest trash cans you guys have your IDS with you yeah oh my God I don't think you guys at least 21 yeah okay can I find a picture thank you are you still in California huh are you still in California okay and you're still in South Carolina yeah okay address information correct on your driver's license I used to live there for college but I'm here now you're here now yeah okay what's your current address uh house or apartment a house OK huh this address is it still your address no I live at I'm in LA okay what's your current address no visiting yeah is the address on your driver's license still accurate is what I mean yeah okay if it's an emergency then I have a different address because I moved my current address is okay alright give me just a minute okay yeah all 16 on pack alpha 33 on pack 0 G13 driver's license yeah I'm pretty sure she gave me a fake ID let's try it by name real quick but I'm pretty sure it's not gonna come back okay out of a California or the South Carolina I'm sorry South Carolina alright we're trying to check on it OK last name papa Echo Charlie uniform November Echo Sierra first name India Sierra Alpha Bravo Echo Lima Lima Alpha middle is m Mike 2 10 of 0 1 white female made it a little bit of sound alright copy okay alright stand up for me stand up for what stand up put your hands behind your back for what do not resist me or you're gonna go to the ground do not pull away from me put your hands behind your back for what put your hands behind your back or you're gonna go to the ground I don't wanna hurt you put your hands behind your back no look I get it but can you just explain you provided me with a fake ID put your hands behind put your hands behind your back we'll get it for about a minute put your hands behind your back I'm gonna tell you again if you cannot do what I tell you to do you're gonna go to the ground and get a resisting charge relax your hands put your hands together like you're praying алекс давай сфотографируем я хочу сфотографироваться сфотографироваться сделай ну как будто бы нет ну как будто бы кто даже не смотрит а сфотографироваться дай I want secured can I pack all my stuff one security I'm gonna go over here in my truck and we're gonna figure out who you really are okay I'm sorry sir what do I do I just sit there yep just hang tight for right now okay cause I still have your ID your information okay but you're not free to go yet okay alright let's start again okay that was my friend's idea that's like a 80 year old lady ok it's not an eighty year old lady i have her picture pulled up the driver's license number that's on that it's a fake id she's like twenty four ok well your friend has a terrible fake id because when i run the number i get the real person's picture back and it's not that oh ok ok it's like a seventy something year old lady so whoever made y'all's fake id did a shitty job okay you could have at least picked somebody young I don't think that was even a fake ID oh it's fake I promise you it's fake oh I didn't know well you did know cause it's not yours well I know that it wasn't mine that's that lady's not when I run that number driver's license number that's what comes up yeah not you yeah I don't know okay so you have now provided me with a fake ID so what is your last name is this necessary it is necessary can you just take the ID and let me go I can take you to jail right now for what well let's see for providing a false name for possession of a fake identification card and alcohol on the beach alcohol is not allowed on it is not allowed on the beach that's why I can't that's why I stopped out with you in the first place person that lives here told me that alcohol was they told you wrong so what is your last name what is your first name what's your middle initial I don't have a middle name OK what is your date of birth uh what year 2007 that's why you gave me a fake ID cause you're not 21 I'm not stupid I work on the beach I deal with this 10 times a day it is not my first day what state is your ID from is it Florida or is it no South Carolina South Carolina wow hold on 15 seconds alright South Carolina by name let's try this time how old are you me uh huh uh I'm 18 last name first name I'm a female out of South Carolina um how many further charges are there well right now you're just at the ones that I talked to you about so we'll see where this goes what we got oh she gave me a fake ID yeah sorry about that and when I run the deal number comes back to like a 70 year old lady I'm sorry with a picture I didn't know it wasn't my fake it was my friend's fake but you provided it to try to identify yourself with that can you stand by with her for a second Joe yep good your subject came back negative norxine out of South Carolina your last name is correct yeah your first name is exactly I didn't do anything don't don't listen to him okay but they're right that'll get you in trouble yeah oh I need my glasses I don't know what you're talking about where are you from I'm from California what are you doing here uh I'm gonna go to college here huh I'm gonna go to college here what college days on the state how did you move to California from California my sister lives here yeah is that your sister over there no goddamn Jake what we get let me get go get let me get my glasses OK give me one sec yeah fucking die out here can I go talk to her real quick well let's talk to her a second what are you gonna study um radiology OK and you have an ID or a driver's license in South Carolina uh no I what state do you have an ID in in Florida yes is there anything else you're not telling us huh is there anything else you're not telling us no it's just so much easier when you're truthful yeah I guess do you have any warrants what's a warrant well they wanna take you to jail I don't know what a warrant is you don't know what a warrant is it's a piece of paper that says you have to go to jail by the order of the court okay is that it airport and sure that was dirty what part of South Carolina yep alright um I got some good news I got some bad news okay the good news is I am not gonna charge you with providing me with a false name OK the bad news is you have a fake ID OK and and it is unlawful to have a fake ID OK and it is unlawful to provide a fake ID to law enforcement okay yeah certain things I have discretion on right meaning I can write you a ticket I can take you to jail whatever certain things I have discretion on certain things I don't have discretion on yeah okay the fake ID part you're gonna be taking a ride today okay so you are under arrest okay um you want her to have your belongings I'll hold on to them for you yeah OK do you have any shorts that she can put on I'm just gonna say do you have do you have some pants she can put on OK I'm just gonna hold on to you because you can't if you trip and fall you can't brace yourself can you give me my shorts yeah yeah see you later OK yeah the state statue yeah 2 88 5 65 $66 for the statue to be yeah thanks can you put them all on yeah I will give me a second bro yeah I'm sorry she said bro hahaha you got no top I'm gonna brush your hair I'll check it now you got a shirt you want a T-shirt that she can just hold on she can put it on when she gets out there okay that's alright you're good they'll give you one I can just where's your ID at where's your ID at alright come over here I'm gonna have you sit in the truck for a second and we'll get the rest going can I put my shoes on uh yeah we'll bring them with us there you go watch your knee okay this is my old address video I just put one over here in 15 seconds alright come on talk to her while he fix this up alright she wants to talk to you before we go what's so funny OK wait what is so funny with you what's so funny she what's so funny with you and I'm sick of those whatever so what's gonna happen is whatever what's gonna happen is um what the poop pillow yeah OK he's a friendly poop you should like that so what's gonna happen is that I called Aisha I called your mom you're gonna be taken to jail but you're not two things when you are да блядь что что мне делать кто просил что что мне делать никому не говорите вот и всё никому не говорите но у тебя рот как будто бы ты срёшь изо рта мне это так надоело про тебя I don't Wanna talk to you anymore yeah cause she's fucking ah what's she mad about I don't know no secrets secrets don't make friends what's she mad about oh she fucking told everyone like bro why but why does she feel the need to tell people I think she's trying to like she could have just kept it between the two of us I think she's trying to help you out okay but she could have kept it between the two of us but her intentions were good right I don't even know alright let's get the show on the road let's get you down there so you can get out OK is she gonna come she said she is she gonna come on in the other car no she's not coming in the other car we'll look like Uber well I don't know she's gonna have to drive out there and bond your ass out yes she doesn't have a car how'd you get here uh Uber I'll bond you out sounds like she's being mean to me you hear that don't be mean don't be mean she'll leave you in there hey listen I'm paying for your bone bro yeah and if you're mean to her she can she can kick you cause she doesn't care if she messed up her foot cause she's getting fixed anyways no I'm getting picked up by Aisha and then we're gonna come to you and bone you out what are you you don't really have much of a choice I'm just gonna say how you gonna tilt your head back she's helping you out oh she could make you sit in there till tomorrow she could make me shit out of my mouth oh oh oh my god that was literally like five minutes ago I don't know Russian but that's funny cause I got a shit pillow right there she said I'm shitting out of my mouth hahaha because I was like I told my sister I mean an alternative she's looking at a shit pillow so maybe that's the first thing that came to mind alright you ready alright you know where you're going I give you the number and I give you the number of the branch show my guy alright what do we learn today we Learned that you cannot drink at the beach in Florida okay and that well or anywhere in the state of Florida but you can all have a fake ID ah okay I don't what's the last thing we Learned huh what's the last thing we Learned you can't drink anywhere in the state of Florida underage that works I always try to get three alright you can't drink underage in Florida alright I believe you alright alright go bond her out good luck with the toe thank you enjoy your time in Florida thank you if they don't kick me out of the house yeah you didn't get in trouble hey but I feel bad she was with me alright well alright we're working on what we're gonna do because they're having they're having some problems in there it's gonna be a while so we're just trying to figure out what we're gonna do okay appreciate it alright we're gonna switch cars for a minute okay you're gonna go in the van till they're done in there they they got some problems in there right now they're trying to work through alright I gotta ask you a couple questions you see a doctor in 24 hours have you seen the doctor in 24 hours no it's not a hard question do you have anything on you on your person no she when I was in contact with her she's basically in a G string OK not really anywhere you can hide anything do you have any other personal items with you no no cash no phone nothing OK I'm just gonna wait for the hot truck I think there's so much heat OK no you're fine I'll just stay here I'll do that in front of you because all the time yeah $400 nope that's why I can have my phone here I'll get the cuffs off you want a cup of water oh you get out of here then yeah these guys I don't know what your policy is in the van with the jewelry but I didn't take it off so you're not suicidal right no what you are suicidal no are you pregnant no those are all questions we're gonna ask you and I expect the same answers okay Russian is your first language right yeah okay that's no but you speak English no no she does but sometimes it takes a second okay when you ask her the question yes no because I do the same thing no I know no I I need to because all of a sudden she goes oh I'm pregnant no I get it I I need to see a doctor under Terry v Ohio 392 U S 1 1 9 6 8 an investigative detention is lawful when supported by specific articulable facts establishing reasonable suspicion direct observation of open alcoholic containers in a zone restricted by Velusia County Code Section 2 2 to 4 satisfies this threshold without ambiguity the initial stop carries no Fourth Amendment vulnerability Florida statue Section 322.212 classifies possession or display of a fraudulent identification card as a third degree felony under Illinois v Gates 462 US 2 one three one nine eight three probable cause is a totality of circumstances determination when the David system returns a non matching photograph that discrepancy alone constitutes independent probable cause for arrest without any further investigative steps required Burke m R v McCarthy 468 U s 4 2 0 1 9 8 4 holds that investigative detention prior to formal arrest does not constitute custodial interrogation Miranda warnings are not triggered at this stage the subject's voluntary disclosure of a 2007 birth year is admissible and independently supports a second charge under Florida Statute Section 562.111 possession of alcohol by a person under 21 Graham v Conner 490 U s 3 8 6 1 9 8 9 requires force to be evaluated from the perspective of a reasonable officer at the moment of the decision verbal resistance followed by initial physical non compliance during handcuffing justifies controlled restraint the officer's measured response falls within Graham's proportionality standard hibble v Sixth Judicial District 542 U S 1 7 7 2 0 0 4 confirms that stop and identify statutes do not violate the fourth or Fifth Amendments in Florida a stop and identify jurisdiction demanding true identity after confirmation of a fraudulent document is constitutionally sound continued refusal to identify at this stage constitutes an independent criminal act Florida Statue Section 843.0855 governs false identification to law enforcement and is a misdemeanor carrying officer discretion Florida Statue section 322.212 carries no comparable discretion once fraudulent evidence is objectively confirmed the officer's decision to wave the misdemeanor charge while enforcing the felony reflects statutory accuracy not selective enforcement this distinction is critical in any subsequent uh section 1,983 civil rights challenge pre booking intake screening is mandatory under Florida model jail standards failure creates institutional liability under 42 USC section 1,983 Title 6 of the Civil Rights Act of 1,964 further requires meaningful language access for limited English proficiency individuals at all critical stages of the criminal process including arrest booking and first appearance hearings under Florida Rule of Criminal Procedure Sanderd E Sanling the controlling lesson in this encounter is structural a civil infraction predicated a lawful Terry stop the Terry stop produced a fraudulent document the document established probable cause under Illinois v Gates the arrest was proportionate under Graham v Connor each enforcement action was anchored to a prior lawful predicate any break in that evidentiary chain creates constitutional exposure for suppression motions civil liability under section 1,983 and potential dismissal of all derivative charges