I'm searching money oh I actually know you yeah haha you came when my mom passed away you can came help ma'am you need to step out of the car please that's simple I don't want you to get criminal charge ah this is something stupid action when a driver refuses to accept that the law is the law a suspended license no insurance a ceased tag order and a driver who believed none of it applied to her hi how you doing I'm sergeant Monroe oh I actually know you yeah you came when my mom passed away you can came help thank you yeah I'm sorry about that so did you switch insurance recently insurance on your car did you miss a payment or something so what they're telling me is that your license is suspended okay how come it to be suspended yeah a lot of times what it shows me is a financial responsibility suspension so a lot of times what it shows me is that it'll happen a lot when people switch insurance or miss insurance payments if you do that your insurance will lapse though you know I'm sick and tired because they play with me with every month's up down up down up down and sending this information is because today in the internet it's a big mess no I'm driving safe I'm watching how I'm driving nobody could suspend it's not a law if you have if you have like if you have you're required to have motor vehicle liability insurance in the state of Florida show me the law I will gladly show you the law show me the law if if you don't have insurance that's also a crime you can go to jail it's not a crime yes it is no it's not a crime ma'am I'm not gonna argue with them it's the law it's show me the law I will gladly show you the law show me the law I have a written law about that okay and I'm letting you know that it is a crime I'll be right back with you we're not doing this I just wrote her the 1:16 failure carry liability insurance cause I'm a nice guy that's the impression though that's not mandatory court date I know ma'am uh so not only did I print you out the statute that covers that you're required to carry motor vehicle liability insurance I carry I printed you out everyone and I printed you out why your license is suspended and why you're being issued citations I also need to explain to you that you're not able to drive this vehicle there's a cease tag order on your car that I have to take you know what it's a State Farm agency over there who made that law artificial intelligence no or civilians and like ma'am this is the law I'm not gonna argue with you about it what I need you to do is call for a ride you cannot move this car from where it is right now you don't have motor vehicle liability insurance stop telling me this awful thing they know how many people driving without insurance so my question is right now now you suspended license so whole half state light riding with suspended license yes you're currently driving while your license is suspended you cannot suspend my license alright well if you have a problem with it yes well what you can take these to court and argue that with the judge and I'm sure it's not gonna go your way if this is artificial intelligence print you this no I printed it you're supposed to put your brain OK listen this is what listen this is what's gonna happen I have to take your tag I have to turn it into DMV oh you're not gonna move this car this car an inch I will take you to jail do you understand I guarantee you I will so what you're gonna do is call for a ride but it's a awful thing to do that to people okay this is why you follow the law and do what you're supposed to do because we we build in gold America like this you work no let's go together let's drive together no you are not moving this car from this spot alright I need you to get out of the car hey I'm gonna put this down then she's getting out of the car hold on OK just listen to me just roll down the window for a second I'm here and well but like this window like this OK so here's the deal if you have any issues with anything alright don't make it criminal so far everything is civil let me finish now I'm not okay you're not a criminal as of right now you're not ma'am listen to me for a second let me explain something to you here's the here's the issue right now it's everything civil that can go in the court and be done with it but if you refuse for all lawful order the sergeant is give you and you refuse to listen to his orders you can get charged for obstruction which is a criminal matter I don't want you to get criminal charges you have to stay on my side because I am staying on side I'm not I didn't suspend it ma'am you need to step out of car you're gonna get pulled out of the car step out of car ma'am ma'am this is a lawful order you need to this is a lawful order you you're going to get arrested for obstruction if you don't step out of the car I'm not playing sick ma'am if you don't step out of the car you are going to get arrested for obstruction you understand that ma'am you don't want that ma'am please just step out of the car ma'am it's very simple you're gonna go to jail if you don't step out ma'am open your door please you're gonna go to jail if you don't step out the car and you're gonna get a window busted out OK ma'am you need to step out of the car please that's simple I don't want you to get a criminal charge wow this is complete stupid action get out of the car get out of the car look at this guy get out of the car look at this guy look at this this is America wow get out of the car wow get out of the car wow this is America golden America watch every George people golden America we're building you did this to yourself this could have been real simple yeah yeah 445 I'm not a white female 10:15 you're gonna answer for your actions before Trump before Mr Trump you gonna answer for your actions I can't do it you gonna answer for your actions before Mr Trump you heard me yes ma'am yes okay ma'am you made something that was really simple very difficult today you gonna answer before Trump for this kind of have a seat OK I will you're gonna be very very disappointed see I can't move my leg it's not working hey so what kind of golden America we're building you sit inside that kind of America we're living stay inside go back inside and let me rest you a little bit I already show you how we gonna OK very beautiful I'm here at the building it is land of opportunity in Florida this traffic stop ended with a broken window and a criminal arrest for obstruction was the officer legally justified was the arrest constitutionally sound the answer lies in the statutes and the case law Florida Statue 627 733 requires all motor vehicle operators to maintain personal injury Protection of at least 10 $0 Florida Statue 324 22 adds a property damage liability requirement when coverage lapses the insurer notifies the DHSMV automatically under Florida Statute 322 251 the license is then suspended as an administrative action by the state agency not the officer this distinction is legally critical the officer on scene has no authority to lift the suspension the officer can only enforce what the database reports a seize tag order means the license plate must be seized on the spot under Florida law this is a legal obligation not a discretionary call the vehicle cannot be moved from its current location the officer printed and delivered the relevant statute to the driver under Florida Statute 316 dot 646 this is not merely courtesy it documents that the driver was fully informed of the legal basis for each citation the authority to order a driver from the vehicle comes from Pennsylvania v Mims 434 US 106 decided in 1,977 The Supreme Court held this is lawful as a matter of course during any a valid traffic stop the court found that the officer's legitimate safety interest outweighs the minimal intrusion on personal liberty this doctrine is not subject to the driver's consent or disagreement refusing that order is a crime under Florida Statute 843 obstruction of a law enforcement officer without violence a first degree misdemeanor carrying up to one year in county jail the force used to break the window and extract the driver is evaluated under Graham v Conner 490 US 386 decided in 1,989 the Supreme Court established the objective reasonableness standard three factors govern the analysis severity of the crime at issue whether the subject poses an immediate threat to officer safety and whether the subject is actively resisting or attempting to evade here the subject refused multiple lawful orders over an extended period received a specific advance warning that the window would be broken and continued to resist despite a separate de escalation intervention under Graham v Conner documented warnings at each escalation step significantly strengthen the legal justification for the force applied the backup officer's civil versus criminal warning is part of that record legal lesson 1 a financial responsibility suspension is administrative not punitive it is reversed by restoring insurance and paying DHSMV reinstatement fees the courthouse not the roadside is the proper venue for legal challenges legal lesson 2 the right to question the law does not authorize refusing lawful orders citizens may dispute citations before a judge they may not block enforcement at the scene legal lesson 3 when officers give documented verbal and repeated advance warnings before applying force the legal defense for that force is substantially stronger and civil liability exposure is significantly reduced but this case raises a question Florida courts have not fully resolved when insurance systems report lapses automatically to the DHS and v how quickly are drivers actually notified that their license has been suspended if a driver is genuinely unaware of the suspension does that change the legal or moral analysis the statute does not require knowledge of the suspension to enforce it but the absence of a knowledge requirement raises a deeper question at what point does administrative enforcement create due process concerns under the 14th Amendment that argument has been tested in courts with inconsistent results was this a failure of the driver the insurance system or both did the officers have every legal tool available and use them correctly or were there procedural steps that could have changed the outcome entirely the law provided a framework the officers followed it the driver chose a different path whether that path was a choice or a consequence of the system is the question this case leaves open