would you call the public yeah okay uh we had Miss Massie wanted to call the public am I the only one yeah um so I'm going to take this time um I know you guys need to go into to e session so out of respect for that um the item that I had requested to speak on earlier was during the content agenda item number six is it pertains to the contract of employment for the City attorney um so I'm going to start this off with in the contractual agreement with Mr Robert Wingo there is a stipulation that St that says he can renegotiate his pay rate for an exceptional job um Cambridge University defines exceptional as something that is much greater than usual especially in skill intelligence quality Etc I.E what is not expected of somebody in a role and I have concerns with allocating more funds to him specifically for a few different reasons Point number one is according to an article that was published in the surprise independent just shy of 12 months ago by Jason Stone um the City attorney is the second highest paid individual in the entirety of the city of surprise employees and at that time he was listed at making about $266,000 annually where this becomes important is he is 11th overall in the entire State and he actually only makes only $10,000 again at the time of the article was printed less than the attorney in Scottdale and Scottsdale has about 100,000 people larger than what surprise covers um recent months have uncovered numerous violations or alleged violations in blatant disregard I would say for not only the Arizona revised statutes the State Bar rules of professional conduct but Al the Arizona State Constitution and the Bill of Rights at the federal level um title 16 I won't rehash everything but we are all too well and familiar with what took place during the election season and the violations thereof city clerk is our elections officer nothing was done with the violations and the City attorney did nothing as far as that title 9 and 38 have conflict of interest pieces of information and it was deemed that there was a conflict of interest title 39 there are numerous public records requests that I have open right now that are quote pending legal review that I am entitled to request I've got to interrupt you here because okay are you going to stop the timer this is the public meeting Forum that you agree to when you speak and I want to read this to you that um there are oral Communications during the city council meeting may not be used to Lodge charges or complaints again any employee of the city or members of the body regardless of whether such person is identified in the presentation by the name or by any other reference that tends to identify him or her that's all fine well and good but that's a VI violation of My First Amendment right so that's well this is your warning okay warning for what warning for attacking the City attorney personally um this is all factual information it doesn't matter you're violating My First Amendment right this is what you agree to when you for speaking this is the form it is unconstitutional mayor well it's not unconstitutional and if you're the Supreme Court has up I could get up here and I could swear at you for three straight minutes and it is protected speech by the Supreme Court it is why don't you look at case law no you can't I can so if you want to be also the chair is Eng be you want to be escorted out of here do you want to be escorted out of here violating My First Amendment rights talking you are violating My First Amendment rights that's your opinion it's not a matter of opinion do you want to be escorted out Miss Massie because that's what's going to happen and it's going to happen in the future also anytime you attack that's why you change the rules or any that's why you Chang the rules this has been on the back of this form I understand mayor Hall but that is completely unconstitutional no it's not you're also engaging in debate and so you should actually be yelding the floor to somebody else managing Chief could you have somebody come down here and and escort Miss Mass really is that necessary yes I in front of my 10-year-old daughter you're going to escort me out for expressing my can go with you she can go with you I'm not leaving well you just with me um I'm no I'm expressing my f do not touch me do not put your hands on me you just that with me do not put your hands on me come on out do not put your hands on me come out with me now before you get arrested you understand this are you detaining me yes you why am I being detained under What charges under what Char okay so I'll I have personal property I have you cannot yeah she can go out there okay uh I'll I'll entertain a motion to go into e session motion to go into e session second then mooved to Second it all those in favor say I I we're going into e session contact information for the City of Surprise and the Surprise Police Department which dragged this woman out by force is listed below this city hall meeting was on August 20th 2024 as soon as I have the date for the next city hall meeting I will let you guys know what it is and I will see you there in person I don't care if you agree or disagree with Miss Massie on anything quite frankly I don't agree with her on a lot of things but as Americans we don't stand by and watch government use force and violence to attack their critics whether we agree or disagree with those critics hey mayor Skip Hall surprise [ __ ]