take the freaking cuff off so I can get my lawsuit You corrupt pig They're taking it off This police officer claims to have stopped to check on this guy just to help him to make sure that he was all right Well he was driving by I saw the window and I want to make sure everything was all right But the guy was fine and he did not want any interaction at all with the police And gee he really did help him Peppering him with questions harassing him threatening him with violence Do you have your ID handy sir what's your first name none of your business So get out of my sight I don't have to leave Your car and do your job How about you go pick up some litter out here do something Stop harassing me Is this a public roadway it's a public roadway So I don't have to move Harassing is a repeated behavior Sir that's very disrespectful and rude One way or another you're going to come out of this car You need to watch YouTube videos because you need to stop watching YouTube videos I'm going to break I'm going to end up breaking this window Do not start that car Why are you stopping do not start that car ultimately putting him in handcuffs looking for any reason at all to jam the guy up When I ran the tag it comes back same name Okay the birthday could be off Th This is who the hits for It's so close So why was it that despite this cop's best efforts he was forced to let this guy go in humiliating fashion let's take him out of handcuffs Lawsuit you corrupt pig Lawsuit Okay lawsuit Give me all of their names right now Let's break it down Everything requires a subscription now And the worst part about it is that if you're like me you completely forget how many subscriptions you have or how much they are costing you every month And for subscriptions that you don't even use anymore how great would it be if there was an app that kept track of that for you and then helped you to cancel those subscriptions that you don't even use anymore and also help you track your bills That's why I love this video's sponsor Rocket Money Rocket Money is an all-in-one finance app that helps you save more and spend less It allows you to manage subscriptions lower bills build a custom budget and grow your savings all in one place But my absolute favorite part of using Rocket Money is cancelling unwanted subscriptions It securely identifies any recurring charges that you have and allows you to cancel those with just a few taps You never even have to get on the phone They do it all for you and they've helped customers save over $500 million in canceled subscriptions Rocket Money can help negotiate your bills for you No customer service calls Let the apps negotiators do it for you So if you want to save more and spend less go now and join the over 5 million members currently using RocketMoney Here's what you do Go to rocketmoney.com/sivil or click the link in the description to get started for free Get your money right by using Rocket Money Thanks to Rocket Money for sponsoring this video Now let's get back to it This video comes to us from Margate Florida It involves a guy just sitting inside his car that is parked in a public park Officer Sone of the Margate Police Department sees this car sitting there He has not observed any crime being committed Nobody has told him that any crime has been committed Nevertheless he sees something that causes him to want to get out of his police car and approach this guy The issue here is what are the rights what is the law when police officers confront somebody such as this does he have to talk to him is he free to leave can the police officer force him out of the car can they box him in can they harass him can they annoy him all of these cases are highly highly fact dependent The first thing we need to look at is what is the reason for this encounter As far as I can tell this police officer just observed this car Noticed that the two rear windows were halfway down That's it There was no 911 call no crime reported no crime observed This should be starting out here a consensual encounter where just anybody can walk up to anybody and try to engage in conversation But neither of those individuals can forcibly detain the other and stop the other from leaving None of those individuals can force the other to engage in conversation against their consent If ever that point is crossed that becomes a detention And the fourth amendment requires there be reasonable suspicion that can be articulated by the officer So let's proceed and see what exactly is happening here Good morning How you doing how can I help you well I was driving by I saw the window and I want to make sure everything was all right Everything's good Okay Do you have your ID handy sir i don't have a show ID Why not cuz I've committed no crime Okay What's your first name none of your business Okay What's your first name my first badge number 3533 sir What's your name officer S SN All right Continue Have a good day Okay Is this your vehicle sir that's none of your business Okay You don't want to turn this into a lawsuit for you I don't want to turn anything into anything Why are you going to sue me because a majority of you cops are corrupt You don't This is the first time we're ever meeting correct you have no no reason to contact me and I don't like cops I I I don't care what you like or don't like I'm going to do my job Your job isn't harassing me cuz I've given it no crime I'm not harassing you Harassing is a vehicle and continue Harassing is a repeated behavior sir Attacking that vehicle and continue patrolling That's what you can do I don't have to This is a public roadway correct well you can stop harassing me Is this a public roadway it's a public roadway So I don't have to move Someone I don't have to speak to them especially you Mr Car No No Leave Leave my sight Mr Carr leave my sight Mr Carr he's refusing to identify himself or speak to me He was already asked my badge number and said as I'm harassing him Yeah you're harassing me I committed no crime You got no reason to stop me I'm on a legal public roadway So get out of my sight I don't have to leave Your car and do your job How about you go pick up some litter out here Do something That's not my job You You guys are the ones Elon should um fire cuz you do nothing but sit in your car all day sleep with the AC running wasting my tax dollars Go out and find some crime sir Old man crime Mr Carr None of your business Mr Car Okay we'll do this another way Sorry we'll do this another way Yes you do what another way You do what another way all of my shit's legit You can't do anything to me I'll pull a lawsuit out of both of you guys I want to win another lawsuit I want to win another I'm having a hard time seeing your vehicle Does this window go down none of they don't go down and you have no reason to see in my vehicle What what what do you What do you What do we I want able to see you and make sure that everything is good I'm You can see me right here from the front All right Now I can see you So get in your car and get on my sight What's your name and badge number officer Escobar 3545 What is it again officer Escobar 3545 3545 Now get in your car and leave Where's your supervisor i'm sorry Call your supervisor right now I believe my partner is doing that right now Call him right now I believe my partner is doing that right now Complete business Okay 92 If you have another one start one He's our refusing to um identify himself or talk to us or open the door I'm trying to verify who he is Another way a sign of this vehicle photograph matches uh showing I haven't got a telltage but showing an active 99 full extradition for appears to be stalking So the driver believes that this is a case of racial profiling and as it turns out he may be correct about that Officer S ran the tag of this guy's car and when he saw the name and when he saw the picture of the registered owner of the vehicle whom he believes to be the individual he's interacting with he noticed that there was an outstanding warrant for another black guy with the same last name and perhaps the same middle name but a different first name and a different date of birth But wouldn't it be so great if he could arrest that guy it's not exact but it's so close It's so close H Sure Mr Aosta Mr Aosta What What do you want this is your vehicle correct none of your business Are you the registered information right now huh none of your business You will have all of my information So So it is So it is you You are Mr my vehicle I'm not telling you anything because you have no reason to stop me Okay And I'm recording everything I'm recording everything as well sir Pull a well suit out of your [ __ ] That's very disrespectful and rude Who cares if it's disrespectful i have freedom of speech You do And you have no reason to stop me I'm not stopping you I'm in Why are you on my car right now i'm not on your Get your hands off of my vehicle Mr Mr Aosta Listen to me One way or another you're going to come out of this car No I'm not sir I committed no crime You pull me out of this car you'll be you'll be sued I want another suit I want one For what i want one What would you like a lawsuit violate my rights You have no reason to stop me at all Everything's legit and I've given it no crime [ __ ] Very rude sir [ __ ] You need to watch YouTube videos because you need to stop watching YouTube videos I'm going to move my car up now Fired and soup Fired and sue Ass My record is cleaner than any one of you bastards Cleaner than both of you I'm more of a citizen than you Get out of my country You get out Go back to where you came from You corrupt pig Why do I have to get out of your country because you're corrupt We don't need more corrupt bastards like you in America You're the problem with America People like you Mr Aosta People like you Mr Aosta listen to me I don't have to listen to you cuz I committed no crime Mr Aosta I don't have to listen to you You know what you can listen to listen to this Listen I'm going to break I'm going to end up breaking this window break my window and I will have a lawsuit Go ahead and do it as Mr Aosta Mr Aosta go ahead and do my window You're you're on a public roadway When I check the license plate this is a public parking spot Listen to me If you stop interrupting I'm going to explain what's going on There's no people park here every day and you don't harass them You're just racist I'm racist You're racist You pig Can you say hi all of you guys are racist pigs Stop touching my vehicle Get off my car Get your pig hands off my car What's your name and badge number you pig what's your name and badge number you're the reason women shouldn't be cops You're corrupt just like the men Yeah I'll get a lawsuit I'll get a lawsuit from all of you guys I'm going to Margate to file a complaint right now I'm going to get off Do not start Do not start that car Do not start that car Why are you stopping me do not start that car Why are you stopping me i'm going to tell you right now Listen to me Do not start that car Why are you stopping me do not start that car Why are you stopping me i'm going to tell you right now Listen to me Why are you Aosta aosta why are you stopping me aosta listen to me you start this car and you move forward and you damage that vehicle it's going to be a problem right now You are not free to leave Why am I not free to leave because the the registered owner of this vehicle has a warrant and until I don't argue with me I'm going to give you two seconds One I'm going to show you my ID right now Perfect Give it to me For no reason you're harassing me Give me your ID Can you see him show me the warrant No Show me your ID Show me your warrant Give me your ID sir Hold on Let me step out Step out Okay D get away Back away from my door I'm backing away sir You said I have a warrant Show me that warrant Come out here and I'll show it to you I want to make sure I want to make sure you're lying Show me that warrant Why are you touching me why are you harassing me wait a minute Whoa whoa whoa whoa Get my phone I'm I got my IDs in my bag Why are you arresting me oh my god This is a lawsuit This is a lawsuit Officer Son lied to the driver and said that the registered owner of his vehicle has a warrant The guy knew that that wasn't true The officer also lied that he would show him the warrant if he got out of the car And that's when they grab him and they put him in handcuffs And now they've moved straight up the chart to an arrest where now they don't just need reasonable suspicion They either have to have a warrant for his arrest or for a warrantless arrest they have to have probable cause There was no warrant The warrant that officer Sone found was for a different black guy with the same last name Was not for this individual as much as he wanted it to be My my ID is in his bag You guys got your ID Listen to me This is a Listen to me Mr Aosta stop talking and listen Can you guys pick up my phone i'll pick it up now It's in there Let me get it No I'm not letting you do anything cuz you've been This should be in my bag right in there Look you've been completely uncooperative Look is this you that's me Costa Yes No No You have a Florida driver's license It should be in there I'm looking Show me where it is so I see it Look behind the money Look in there It's in there I put my ID in there Look all through there I'm looking It's in there Look in there I'm going to take each thing out for you There you go Let's do this See how hard this is is not a lawsuit I don't care what you say It's a lawsuit It's a lawsuit Lawsuit You illegally you illegally arrested me I'm not You're not arrested I said you detained arrested me You never been arrested You illegally arrested me You're not arrested So you see my name on this yeah Okay This is you Yeah Show me Show me the warrant What's your birthday show me the warrant What's your birthday sir show me the warrant What is your birthday sir okay Thank you This is a lawsuit Thanks for getting me paid you corrupt guys Thanks I'm going to press the issue I'm going to press it Lawsuit for all of you and I'm going to foil all your body cams Lawsuit harassment racism That's what this is You guys are the problem with America You guys people like you Come on Cops Why are you photographing me i'm going to run your face You No no You have no right to put my face in no database You have no right to put my face in the database I'm not going to look at your camera I have no I don't have to look at your camera Okay sir I already You have no right to put me in your database I'm not looking at your camera This is a lawsuit Well sir you're already on body camera You're Who cares but this is this is all this does is adding to your lawsuit You corrupt pigs Okay Get me paid I needed money Yes sir I was waiting for you guys to do something like this I knew it Well I believe you guys are the problem with America I believe you only have a warrant sir You guys are a problem with America You believe see everything is speculation Speculation No facts Speculation He had no reason to pull behind me He had no reason to run my tag And I have no reason to be in these cuffs Man you pigs are going to get me paid Well sir you could run your tag at any time Nope He had no reason to run my tag He had no reason to pull up and step to my car at all You we could run any license plate that we see in public Sir he can't pull up behind me stop his car box me in and run my tag You can't do that I've committed no crime He saw me commit no crime You don't have to commit a crime to run a tag sir All my tags my tag my license everything's legit and this is unlawful Then you say you want to run my face in some some AI This is all criminal It's not criminal It's not AI sir All criminal Your face recognition technology is AI It's federal criminal Yes it is So you're too incompetent You don't even know what your own software is It's not artificial You're all I'm utilizing a real time picture Incompetent and corrupt And you're the problem with American You guys like you Hey it it it might not be him Okay But it's I went out with the car cuz it's parked here I saw the window down I ran the tag as I drove by I came back around went out with the car cuz I saw the hit and I'm like "Hey how you doing Officer Sar Police Department?" So now officer S is explaining apparently to his supervisor why this guy is in handcuffs why he has arrested this guy but then he just told him that he did not arrest him And if he didn't arrest him what the hell is going on and why is the guy in handcuffs what's happening here um went out with him He immediately starts filming me [ __ ] you Get away from me ass wipe I'm not talking to you I'm like sir we're on a public roadway I can I can talk to you Um refuse to identify himself the whole nine yards Also officer Son basically admits the real reason that all of this is happening It's all because when he walked up to the car to quote unquote check on the driver he immediately observed that the driver was filming him with his phone Well he was driving by I saw the window I want to make sure everything was all right that apparently hurt his feelings because you know cops should be the only ones filming I guess in these scenarios And so this whole thing has been retaliation to try to show him who's boss to try to create a found find out situation But fortunately the supervisor just doesn't seem to be buying any of it And soon as he starts asking "Yeah but what about the law?" sort of questions to Sone S completely buckles Uh then I Let me ask you when you read his tag right did that come the the registered owner of the tag that Right But with his birth date now that I have his birth date it could be different But the photo was pretty close That's why I went out with the car But the registered owner of the tag Mhm It's him Did that come back with a warrant when I ran the tag it comes back same name Okay The birthday could be off That's why I'm verifying it So I just asked him for his ID and then he immediately starts and then he said he wanted to come out and talk to us and show us I asked him for his finally when you were pulling up he came out on his own We didn't pull him out of the car and we handcuffed him and detained him so I can verify Okay it's all this is All right Did he just lie to his supervisor is that how it happened oh I was just asking for his ID and then he wanted to get out of the car He wanted to help us and he hopped right out of the car I'm going to break I'm going to end up breaking this window Do not start Do not start that car Do not start that car right now You are you are not free to leave Why am I not free to leave because the the registered owner of this vehicle has a warrant and until I don't argue with me I'm going to give you two seconds One I'm going to show you my ID right now Perfect Give it to me for no reason You're harassing me Give me your ID No I don't think that's what the body cam showed What do you have his de his name and date of birth off of this thing is which is not what is this this is uh certified forklift operator ID shows him as car Aosta which is also a sign of the vehicle The hit is for car Aosta with a very similar date of birth which I'm trying to let me see if I can pull that photo up He's saying Aosta Okay Car Aosta Okay The hits for car Aosta with the date of birth is almost identical Okay So blackmail So let me see if I can pull up car Aosta or Yeah Well let's see if we can find his the actual DL for this guy and David That's I'm going there next I have I have one that's a different name that's a 93% This This looks th this is who the hits for Go ahead It's so close Okay Well let's find the DL for the guy who's a registered owner of this car 104 teletype saying the the DL off this name is clear Okay But this is it's pretty close Well let's find the actual DL That's what I'm doing next I'm pulling that up Dude it was so close Everything's so close Soon as they release me I'm contacting my lawyer and I'm going down to your headquarters as soon as you guys release me Lawsuit racist police and corrupt They know they messed up That's why it's taking them so long They messed up You guys messed up too Tim looks very close It's I mean it's this is the RORO right for the That's him I can't see Sorry I can't turn it anymore Okay This is the guy out of the car Yes Right And what's his date of birth he's saying which is what he gave me But when you pull up the When you pull up the Let me go ahead So let's just stop with the guy who may be and just deal with the guy who we know it is Is the guy who we know it is wanted at all according to the information he's given me this no but it's all right Do we have any charges on him other than him not identifying himself no I can let that go I'll type an alpha about it Well yeah we're going to type an alpha Uh you took these out Let's first off if there's no reason to have them detained any longer it's undetainable Okay All right dude It's What is it is his twin brother lawuit Let's take him out of handcuffs Lawsuit you corrupt pig Lawsuit I'm going to call my lawyer now and I'm going to your headquarters Okay I want all of your names and badges right now Stop tightening that cuff on me Take them off sir Take them off They're doing that Hold on Why are you holding my other arm on top of your head Take it off Put your hand on top of your head Take the freaking cuff off so I can get my lawsuit You corrupt pig They're taking it off Take it off Lawsuit Okay Lawsuit Give me all of their names right now I want their cards now Sawyer 352 I want your cards God damn it I want your cards All of you give me your cards right now There it is No Give me your card No you don't get to hold it Where's my phone it's on your car [ __ ] [ __ ] This is a lawsuit Don't go anywhere This is a lawsuit Where's your name and badge in it show me your ID like he showed me his You want to see my ID i want I want a copy of it My lawyer needs it Can you stand back from your door please stand back from your door I want it on film Can you show it on the on the camera i'm going to take it out for you so you can take a picture of it Lawsuit Okay You feel real shitty now don't you no Let's see yours Lawsuit Let's see yours Lawsuit Let's see yours You can have that Thanks I would like a photo of it but let's see yours Lawsuit Wait wait wait The son got it Can we Sure Yeah You know youed up You pigs Suck my dick,shole No further content Now there are many of us who would watch that and say "Well why didn't he just comply to begin with why didn't he tell him his name why didn't he show ID then none of that would have happened." Do you really think that this officer was walking up to this guy's car because he was worried about him or because he wanted to help him no Nine times out of 10 when a police officer comes up to you and is asking you questions it's because they want to get you They have some hunch or some suspicion that you could have committed a crime or you have a warrant Might be based on the way that you look You don't know It's all in the officer's head When he went up to ask him questions what is he asking him the game he's playing initially is using the ability to engage in a consensual encounter to get the information that he wants to be able to then have reasonable suspicion to detain or even probable cause to arrest That's why he's asking what is your name that's why he's asking are you the registered owner of this vehicle because if he says yes well now if he has this belief even if wrong that the registered owner has a warrant now that's what he's going to use Pull the guy out of the car to detain him or even to arrest him Why answer police officers questions when you have no idea what crazy hunch they have in their head the safest thing to assume is that they're trying to screw you one way or the other Like one of our former presidents said "The scariest thing that you could ever hear is "I'm from the government and I'm here to help." No they're not there to help you They are there to look for some way of taking you away in handcuffs Not because any crime has been committed not because anyone called them The second that this stopped becoming a consensual encounter and became a Terry stop an investigatory detention it was at that moment that the Fourth Amendment was triggered and reasonable suspicion was required For this to be lawful an officer must have specific objective facts not just a hunch indicating that a crime or violation occurred It can't be a hunch It can't be vague feelings or an unsupported intuition Here no objective officer can articulate any reasonable suspicion at all No crime was reported No crime was observed Being parked in a park during daylight hours not a crime Like many of my videos this is a consensual encounter that went bad There's nothing stopping police officers from being proactive and going out in the community If they see something they think is a little off investigating it You can go up to somebody you can ask for ID you can ask questions and if they choose not to interact with you if they choose not to give it to you then you have to deal with it Go find evidence that some crime was committed if that's what you think But many police officers they can't take no for an answer And when they're told no their first response is to retaliate and to demonstrate probably for their their own ego demonstrate their power But when they do that and their hunch turns out to be wrong that's when they get busted just like this guy got busted But fortunately that supervisor was there and he set this guy free As I understand it the guy had filed a formal complaint with the Margate Police Department And I doubt they'll do anything about it but who knows maybe they will Especially if you share this footage The very least we can document what happened to this guy in case things like this are happening again involving the Margate Police Department Our rights don't end where your fear begins Freedom is scary Deal with it