cops are entrusted with authority but what happens when they abuse their power here are four times when idiot cops took it way too far okay you didn't intentionally do that then thought I too yeah it looked like looked right at me and looked like you stuck your middle finger up my face no no I was doing this you must be really sensive well I don't even make it personal you know I mean I you look right at me and if you were like a cigarette or you had doing this this is Sergeant Jay Ryan from the Vermont state police on February 9th 2018 Sergeant reyan pulled over a driver named Greg bombard in St albin's Vermont he was pulled over because the sergeant believed he had flipped him off while going in his vehicle watch what happens when Sergeant Ryan pulls him over by the side of the road for this alleged [Music] offense you need something you need something yeah no it look like you uh put me up and you're going by there like you went like this to me as I was driving by you what you looking did you not do that no you might have thought I have two in this okay so you didn't no okay you didn't intentionally do that then thought I yeah it looked like look right at me and looked like you stck your middle finger up my face no no I was doing this yeah you must be really sensitive at Super you want well I don't even make it personal you know I mean I you look right at me and if you were likeing a cigarette or you had doing first of all I'm not an overly sensitive person and it's the first time in 12 years I've ever stopped someone who I thought put me off so I don't like that insinuation you know what I'm saying in in talking you off want to make sure that you're all right yeah it's an unusual behavior it's unusual behavior you may not have been doing that but I think you can agree that if someone was looking for the attention of a trooper they're probably going to find it by giving them that type of negative signal do you agree with that no I don't know didn't understand that so some if if somebody were to do that can we that may not have been you can we agree if somebody did that for a trth or they're obviously looking for their attention no I wasn't looking for your attention I know I'm not I'm saying if someone did that I'm trying to put you in my mindset from what I was thinking for a moment now that I'm talking to you I realize that that maybe that wasn't the case right you don't strike me as someone who would do that I don't know that until I have a conversation with you agree that that I don't know you until I have a conversation with so I have a question if someone supposed to what is the citation what's the crime so so if somebody somebody flicks me off I don't know if they're siing to try to get my attention because they need new Assistance or they need to have a conversation CU obviously it's not normal behavior so I'm going to have that conversation right it's not normal I'm telling you out of thousands of public interactions I've never seen that at least didn't C my attention but it was so obvious what you did you tell me where street is take a left here take your first left take a left and your first left thank you so I won't take up any more of your time I'm going to tr like C you you're yep you're you're more than welcome to Super at a Shas Barracks but I don't understand why like you saw a I don't I was going by there and your middle finger was extended while you were looking at I was doing this I was doing this I also see you had a cigarette in your hand so it's possible that you had one hand uplo your cigarette [Music] consider so so actually so so you're you're more to so so here here's the issue is that although maybe for expression it is so unusual it requires interven make sure that you need help time trying to Signal my attention or something okay so it may be question but it crosses the line whereas it is so unusual that requires interventure and I'm not going I'm not going to delay anymore on YouTube on listen sir once I realize that you weren't cooking me off you're free to go you understand you you don't now you don't realize I put you off once I realize what if I did put you off then we having a conversation not other things to do than so if I did FP you off Sergeant rean permits Mr bombard to leave after clarifying that he did not show him the middle finger or any abusive gesture Mr bombard then proceeded to ask what would be the consequences if he had flipped him off to which he left the question unanswered and returned to his cop Cruiser for those who don't know abusive gestures as such come under the protection provided to Citizens under the First Amendment of the US Constitution the first amendment protects the right of citizens to freedom of speech watch what Sergeant rean is about to do some arrest thly conduct multiple people around there for send me another unit to uh brainer Street in the city so Brainard in uh off North M unit police [Applause] any okay so so now you're under arrest for or cond get out of the car I'm under arrest for or cond all the people there saying you and calling me all the people there in the public that's a crime s get out of the car under arrest how am I under arrest for disly conduct I'm not going toate this please step out of the car you are under arrest step out of the car how is that disorderly conduct sir how is that a disorderly conduct although the first interaction Al the first listen to me ask me a question although the first interaction may have been an error the second one certainly was not and while your window was down with your middle finger extended you said quot hole yell it and then said you as you drove away and all that public there heard it and saw it so that is your totally conduct 101 step out of the car step out of the car having problems I have a lot of step out of the car step out of the car you're going to be attracted from the car how am I going to step out of the car can I can I meet you at the Barrack no you cannot step out of the car you're under arrest can I call your supervisor he'll be at the barracks when we get there step out of the car you're under arrest how am I under arrest step out of the car I'm going to make you but sir how can you explain to me how that is it's disly of it is tumultous behavior all the motor vehicle traffic there that's you cannot do that it's Tous it's profane behavior in public step out of the car I'm door out of the car I can't believe this surv the your theory of walk back here oh my God it wasn't a problem until became PR you understand that on my hands in the hood oh my God hands in the hood come on can I put your right hand behind your back oh my my car is I'll take care of it I cannot believe this for I cannot believe this the first one may have been an error and the second one certainly how is that disorderly contct I'm not being disorderly how is that causing disly now we can maybe agree or disagree but yelling to and saying you with your hand out of the window in front of what probably little were dozens of people if not over a hundred people in very busy Main Street traffic now that's a toally conduct 101 that first thing may have been an error but after that it certainly wasn't but now I'm wondering but now I'm wondering if maybe you actually did do that as I thought you originally did because only somebody who then would have the the the the audacity cigarette and I you may let me speak now someone who has the audacity to do that someone has the audacity I I've made thousands and thousands of fire stops I don't remember any time I've ever seen someone consciously put me the bird side now now I'm now I'm convinced that you did but that behavior did you actually get the end of the stop okay so you are under arrest and that's the end of the story I don't know what to do here so I'm to what we we going to do is just be compliant I am but I'm not going to answer my questions I guess I'm not I'm not I'm worried about my car I'm not intending you that I'm not ask me any questions I'm worried about my cars there je stay there you're kidding I cannot believe this 24 21 US 23 everything in here it's going to poke me I have any gloves [Music] on well first can you please can I please go nope that sh that ship sailed oh my God I can't believe oh my God almost set now so what happens to my car well it says no parking ins side of the street going to get to where to get to I'll give you a record of your preference come back over here can I get my personal bag I can grab it for you but you can't Sergeant Regan pulled him over again alleging that his profanity could be heard by the public and therefore he was going to be arrested for disorderly conduct Mr bombard was taken out of his car arrested and held in custody for about an hour before the issuance of a citation for disorderly conduct the charge was later dismissed against Mr bombard on February 4th 2021 Mr bombard filed a lawsuit against Sergeant Regan and the state of Vermont the proceedings of this lawsuit are unknown if you think this was the only cop who took way too far wait until you watch this next case I need your ID I'm having broke the law it don't matter I need to Iden put good citizen on I'm not going to put good well you're not going to put my name cuz I'm not giving it to you I have to have broken the law before I have to turn over all that information if you're articula I was called that's fine you can be called you can invest but I'm not going to give up I'm not going to surrender my rights just because you showed up this is Officer David Bailey from the Aria Police Department on September 11th 2018 an independent journalist named Albert bustillos was filming a story outside the Navajo oil refinery in Aria New Mexico as he was recording the exterior of the oil refinery a security guard of the refinery approached him watch what he had to say when he found out about Mr bso's recording are you think a pi the refinery just doing a story um they told me that um you ain't take no videos no pictures yeah I can't go on your property and take pictures I'm on public property [Music] yeah I can take picture of anything oh I can see from public what kind of store you making good for the newspaper or it just depends on who wants to pick it up well is it like for the city of Aria or like if they want it it just depends on who wants to pick it up I come out and get some voll footage cars coming in and out might ask some questions if somebody wants to answer them you know and then uh give it to the General Public give a better understanding of what's going on stuff like that I I get took quite a bit of you people because um on m i it's on M I see a lot of people like I'm independent I don't work for nobody specifically I gather my content and then I put it up for whoever wants it and stuff you know sometimes I have specific interest in mind when I go to a place other times it's just for general knowledge and view footage and stuff you know all this is viewable from public man it's on [Applause] yeah if I can see it from public man I can I can record it can't trespass the eyes you know I'm not going to go on your property oh yeah I know that it's from people but I don't know all safety guys made us if you see anybody filming we have to come and well you can come and talk to me that's fine yeah you know just let them know that I'm not doing nothing illegal I have every every right you know I don't even know you know film me taking pictures you know I can't you know stop that you know yeah that's all it is man no no ill intent I'm just here to take pictures as all and stuff how far back where does your property property line start is it right there or is it back there is this a public road right here well you know from what that's what confused me cuz my view you see the failures that where we walk and we walk check the not make that no hoes so really you see the I'm not really the see the street lights and see the the fire hydrants and all that okay Navajo Refinery didn't put those in the city did so everything on this side of those utility markers is public property you know nobody's property goes all the way up to the street there's there's a an easement you know what I mean public easement and I I won't cross the line or nothing I'm stay out out here I'll walk down that way get some from the backside and and everything but so is this this is a public road Public Access well this the access you go inside the refiner oh is that the gate over there the entrance we have a lot of entrances that the we have around the whole plant we have oh okay like I said right here we have lot of cake too so so what what's basically that goes on here is it just oil refinery just making gas and Diesel on this all right what's your name Manu Manu nice to meet you oh here we go bito uh you can't be taking pictures with mine they got signs up yeah I can man I'm just not going to go on your property and take pictures I'm a public property right now so I can take pictures of anything I can see as the sidewalk goes all the way down to the other end you know and goes on it's all public property bro so I'm not going to cross yall's life all thank you cool man you have a good work see you Mr bustillos argued that the government had installed the fire hydrants and other utilities through easement after his conversation with the security guards he continued his filming within the boundaries of the refinery after the guards observed him for a while they called the cops and reported a suspicious individual outside the fence of the refinery officer Bailey along with officer Marcy Sanchez responded to the call watch how the encounter follows hi can I get your name and badge number that you're making Sanchez our teach Police Department your badge number or ID number I'm unit 7:25 all right thank you what's what can I help you without you I don't need no help I'm just doing a story and I've been on public ement the whole time they crossed onto their property okay so well can I see your ID no ma'am I need your ID I'm having broke the law it don't matter I need to identif you put good citizen on I'm not going to put C well you're not going to put my name cuz I'm not giving it to you I have to have broken the law before I have to turn over that information if you're articula I was called that's fine you can be called you can investigate but I'm not going to give up I'm not going to surrender my rights just because you showed up I have to you're asking for my ID that would be surrendering my fourth well you you identified me so I'd like well you're a public servant exactly there a difference I'm not I'm a free citizen so what is it that you're doing out here exactly what does it look like I'm filming that's it this there's thousands of cameras everywhere except you don't have a body camera n specifically Navajo I am not working for Navajo I'm not in their property that is the only time that their rules apply all over their property it don't matter what what yes on their property there's no Peno code at the bottom of the do not allow uh camera uh record signs meaning it's not a law it is their policy their policies don't apply to me only if I'm on their property then I become subject to their laws and their policies while I'm on public property I'm a free citizen I can record anything that my eyes can see can't trespass my eyes and this DHS m sent out in 2010 to all the installations and Reis in 2017 that we have permission to report record police any government officials in the course of their beauty it doesn't matter if I can see see how I can see it from my eyes I can't get in trouble for that if it's viewable if they want they can build a 30ft to wall and then I can't see it but until then I'm allowed to video anything kind of movie are you making your documentary I'm I'm just I'm gathering content for uh matters of interest of the public you're Gathering content for matters of interest to the public that's all it is I'm not going on the property I know my boundaries I do this for living I know the law I might not know all the laws but I know these laws specifically it doesn't matter oh I'm just curious this this is one thing you know making documentaries I do a lot lot of stuff with it just depends what I feel like and who's going to pick it up who's going to buy it or if I'm just going to post it or whatever you know I don't work for nobody specifically I'm an independent journalist Gathering content for story is up that's all I'm doing [Music] never you know I have to be I have to be committing a crime to have give ID no sir yes I do sir yes I do want it bet yes sir you have to articulate a crime that I've either committed I'm committed or I'm about to commit sir you don't want to bet yes sir all right you better call your supervisor if you do something stupid okay call your supervisor don't matter you can call you can you can come and you can come investigate here we you are the suspect we were called here to deal with therefore you are required not suspicion isn't a crime suspicion isn't a crime it's not a felony or a misdemeanor yes it is yes it does that is the law have to you have to articulate a crime I've committed a crime I am committing or crime you are is fair to ID no no no that can be the first crime unless I've committed one then you can get me for for failure until then just for me walking on the sidewalk is not permissible for me to give you ID okay I don't have to give nothing unless I've been I've committed a crime you better go back and and read up the law I can't feel all I want look all of it you everything no matter it's posted that's not the law do you see a Pinal code under the sign no if it was if it was a law there would be a Pinal code I'm not on their property those laws those rules don't apply to me unless I'm on their property I'm on public access that means I'm a free citizen it does matter you're ignorant if you don't know the law you got that badge and that gun but you don't even know how you going to enforce something when you don't I'm not giving you my ID all right turn put back here we go guys put this here so I can all right Mr bustillos was arrested and charged with concealing identity later during the court proceedings Mr bustillos was found not guilty of the charge on September 11th 2020 Mr bsos filed a lawsuit against officer Bailey and the City of Aria the proceedings of this lawsuit are uncertain if you think this was the maximum a cop can take way too far then you probably aren't aware of this next case sir I'm just trying to listen we're just doing a welfare check on you yes I bu be yes not right now I need to talk to you back he don't want to talk it doesn't matter hey come here come here well if you're suicidal that is a crme this is Officer Haley Johnson from the stutgart police department on October 31st 2023 officer Johnson was accompanied by Sergeant Williams they responded to a call regarding a Walmart employee named Nathan Argent making threats against him via text with his wife the officers reported to the parking lot of Walmart and stut guard Arkansas where they found Mr Argent watch how the interaction unfolds hi Bob are you Nathan all is your name Nathan hey so your wife wanted us to check on you my wife yeah are you going through something um yeah but can you put your hands out of your pocket for me no you're good no no hey I need you to come back over here and talk to me though that's a order hi sir yes or no sir I'm just trying to listen we're just doing a welfare check on you Sergeant Williams informs Mr Argent that he's being detained considering the call they received from their wife watch what the officers are about to do yes I I being yes not right now I need to talk to you get back he don't want to talk does matter hey come here come here well it's not wasting your time right now you're we got to call so what's going on what well if you're suicidal that is a crime it's a crime to be suicidal I'm not suicidal so well that's not what we got well that's do you have your IDE on you nope you're going to go to jail walk away been taking the sergeant Williams threatens to take Mr Argent to prison for obstruction if he fails to comply by walking away from the investigation but when Mr Argent refuses to answer questions Sergeant Williams handcuffs him for those who don't know refusing to answer questions is a fifth amendment protected activity according to the Fifth Amendment citizens can refuse to answer questions asked by law enforcement if they believe they can be unreasonably incriminated watch how the encounter follows if you walk away from me you're going to jail really yes obstruction so keep arguing I'm being detained for what we got a call we here to talk to you I don't care if you want to talk to us or not okay so you just going to keep me out in the cold I will so what is going on I'm not talking to you that's fine go and turn around oh boy you can detain me without handcuffs I think just intimidating [Music] me all right FR of work for this okay all right you have anything that's going to poke stick or stab don't know you don't know probably okay if there is any anything in there can you please let us know he that's fine because if anything does tell me that's a Tru really really you're own I told you something might be in there and it might I'm sorry are you such a me huh why are you cuz this is this is more than it is I'm obviously not obstructing you you obviously wear okay but when you walk away from us when we're here legally and you were detained that is obstruction walk away from you you were still walking Sergeant Williams also conducted a thorough search of Mr Argent and placed his personal belongings on the hood of the cop Cruiser this might be an unlawful search under the Fourth Amendment for those who don't know the fourth amendment protects the rights of citizens against unreasonable searches and seizures observe how the encounter ends at first that was before you told me I was detained and it will s on your body can [ __ ] plot you're just violating my right there no violation you're under arrest rest is p arrest hello do you know who is over the construction for tonight uh I can call somebody okay bring okay uh yeah go ahead and send it to me all right this one okay it's it's not you so we uh came over here to do a welfare check on a Nathan [Music] Argent um I don't have his driver's license hold on he drives a Prius with a wre camera go okay okay he's been arrested oh [ __ ] okay so we came over here to do a welfare check we his wife said that he's been threatening to kill himself that she's been trying to beg him to come home I knew something wrong with in the last couple days of the project he was off so um he was walking away from his car whenever he pulled up and I asked the other officer do you know is that him she was like I never even saw that person so I did my little whoop whoop at him ignored it did it two more times he looked back and kept on walking refused to talk to me you know hey I need to know if you're okay I a't got to talk to you walks off so he's going to jail okay I don't know what you want to do with this car out there oh I mean dude's like two hours away from home yeah Atkins or Elkins something like that what's when will he be released uh I personally don't know if the gel will be holding misdemeanor so it's possible that that he'll go down there to DWI and just get oard but he'll be on the streets and DWI but um how far is that way like an hour 30 minutes 30 minutes it's it's 25 miles it's not it's not too terrible but I I do suggest that I mean I'm going to call his wife when we're done here cuz he was very agitated with us when oh yeah had an attitude when I asked to get his hands out of his pockets cuz you know we were told that he likes to carry knives and sharp objects went to Pat him down is there anything in here that's going to stick or poke me you'll find out oh wow so um yeah that's not that's not something you want to hear yeah I mean honestly I hate to see dude stuff go to get impounded and stuff I hate to see him get Stu well we're not going to to it because we never actually physically saw him inside the car okay so we didn't search his car we don't know what's in it um we know he had a box Cut that's probably from working up in here but I think we're just going to get him with obstruction just because he wouldn't like sit there talk to us didn't want to give us his ID we already knew who he was but um see last I heard a couple weeks ago him and his wife or ex-wife was having issues mhm what was the Subaru he drove first and window was busted out of it nice inent on it he said xwi and then couple weeks later he shows up in that PRI saying they're trying to get back together so I'm like I don't see that working well if she busted my windshield I wouldn't want to be back with her um well the car I mean the car is the car can sit out there well if youall have to move it I'm concerned because it's literally parked in between those containers out there oh them are his containers oh they are well one of them is okay they it should be fine he would he let you move the car oh we we have all the property that was on him the keys were in his pocket so can we move it oh we no he's headed to jail now oh he's already left yeah okay um it's Prius it's that w w PRI just pick it up and move it um I just want to let you know cuz I know he was headed back up in here and he's not going to be coming back I'm I'm not going to lie to I'm a little upset with you now I'm so listen you're basically done actually it's going to be these people mad at you cuz the camera ain't me going to be the big box Kevin Newton I don't want to get on his bad side either but stuff happens it's understand you got do what you got to do apparently he has a history of like mental health issues and he had medication in his pocket that didn't have his name on the bottle was like a Daniel F something I don't know I'll contact Ryan my boss and let him know so they can see somebody else out yeah cuz he's third party that be you but I I don't want to you know we wouldn't we wouldn't to his car in point yeah I just thought he was going to have figure out get it been nice if I could have moved it for you all him off yeah well Mr Argent was arrested and taken to the Arkansas County Detention Center he was charged with obstruction of governmental operations and theft by receiving the charges against Mr Argent were later dropped however he was fired from his job at Walmart Mr Argent has started a GoFundMe campaign to help him file a lawsuit if you think this was the last cop who took way too far then you probably haven't seen this next case to ask my ni I have to have to commit a crime or a traffic infraction I honed at you because you're blocking the way of your car other me your I'll put it back in my pocket your Eagle's really this big I haunted you very nicely one time for you to move out the way he wants to continue I have an emergency that's why I me the emergency this is Officer Daniels from the Miami Dade Police Department on July 28th 2022 a couple Mr Kevin and ciso and Miss Sabrina were driving driving to Jackson Memorial Hospital West Campus in Dural Florida after Consulting a doctor M Sabrina was pregnant and was involved in a car accident a day before this incident she was in pain and the doctors wanted to check if she was suffering from a miscarriage the cop Cruisers stood in their way in the parking lot Mr eniso honked at them to which officer Daniels exited his cop Cruiser and approached Mr eniso watch what is about to unfold sure so what are you pulling me off of for for what are you pulling me what are you pulling me over for can can I have your sergeant sir give me your license can I have your sergeant give me your license I've asked for your supervisor [Music] already let me have your license okay I I'm asking for your supervisor call your supervisor call your supervisor let me have your LIC call your super what am I being pulled over for let me have your license to ask my license I have to have to commit aing crime or a traffic infraction I honked at you because you're blocking the way of your car talk to the other let me have your I'll put it my back in my pocket your Eagle's really this big I honked at you very nicely one time for you to move out the way he wants to continue I have an emergency that's why I met the emergency we're going if you you need if you need emergency help that's one thing I already told you that first thing I told you when I open this window you let me my emergency super turn your call off turn your call off I don't need to turn my car off turn your car call your super turn your car off turn your car off get out the car get out the car get out the car stand over there or seizures oh so you okay now I had an accident okay are you okay LA are you okay you want are you okay no I'm okay we have a seat have a seat have a seat I don't have to have a seat have a seat you say you need fire rescue have a seat I don't need fire rescue at a SE fine I'm not being aggressive I'm fine can you start fire rescue this way young lady say she's been involved an accident let me have your license sir what in what infraction let me have your license let me have your license I ref okay we'll deal with you on the more I asked you several times let me have you you ask all you want that's in a command all right what what is she what's the she's going to be seen by her do by her doctor at emergency room to make sure the baby is okay cuz I think I'm getting ready to Mis when was she involved in the accident when late afternoon yesterday yesterday you was involved in the accident yesterday absolutely my doctor stated that's what I needed to do to make sure I don't lose this child as well okay you didn't go to the hospital yesterday CH not to go yesterday okay after you said of my attorney I didn't have to go yesterday but I yesterday after you say you was involved in a in a in a very bad accident yesterday I never said I was in a bad accident I said it was in a car accident yes okay let me see the police report they can't wait okay all right we're going to have fire rescue come and treat you right now sir don't you don't don't don't don't threaten me don't don't threaten me okay do not threaten me do not threaten me nobody's nobody's blocking you move out the way when I have an emergency that's it that's why we're calling Fire Res sir yeah even though right there is emergency room right you still won't show me your driving license sir I let you tell me a lot bro all right we'll get you a supervisor we will get you a supervisor sir I need one as soon as possible you see in this is emergency mode right here this is this we're going to deal with this she's aler she's breathing we care about everybody we care about every officer Daniels requests Mr eniso to step out of the vehicle and display his driving license he ordered them to wait for paramedics to arrive rather than allowing themselves to go to the emergency room observe how the encounter ends you want to for the people you K what why are you saying that for what you trying to antagonize me there no need to antagonize there no need you want me we're going to help you we got fire rescue coming I'm checking I'm looking at her you just having upset bad day today that you want to take it out on us don't do that this is when a good cop stops the other bad cop stop talking to I can talk as much as they want freedom of speech but I guess you tyrants won't understand that right hey how you doing LT all right this young lady here she says that she was involved they were involved in an accident yesterday to can take a vital for me uh this is her name this is her her ID right here she's right there sir step step on the sidewalk over there on the sidewalk stay on the curve stay on the curb sir stay on the curb stay on the curve stay on the curve you should just listen to what he's saying and stay right there what's the reason cuz we're we're treating your your wife right now once they treat her right there okay they cleared your wife okay your wife is cleared okay Che my blood pressure but I know I don't phone your wife is cleared she's okay all right so there no need to Blow Your Horn at us and get and start going off on me and my my part you don't do me over that's not the way you do things is that why you P me over you told us that she was having that why you pulled me over cuz they blew my horn because you were in the way iemergency room okay you've been cleared by fire rescue if you would like to still go in there you can't go over there I'll be working this right here this is my off duty job right here I'm here I'm here till 10:00 tonight I'll wait over there you're going to wait over there now correct okay and what's and what is your name Kevin and C let me see your driving license so I can let him know who's coming let me see your driving license sir him when he gets here tell me your name again Kevin Ando all right Kevin and ciso go ahead Miss go ahead all right we get up the deal he said that his wife is having some emergency fire that's why I I stopped him right here contact fire rescue and of course she's walking in right now she was clear and now she's still she's walking in he just wanted to be he wanted to call something here The reason why I can't is the CEO of the building called cuz they were kind of concerned you know they saw two police car and then you know they just want to know everything was okay okay I'm going to go over here and then uh sit out here and see what this guy's deal is going to be eventually officer Daniels allowed the couple to leave officer Daniels alleges that Mr eniso had directed profanities and abusive remarks toward him the couple stayed in the hospital for several hours after this encounter and it was found that Miss Sabrina was not miscarrying the couple later filed a complaint against the officers involved this resulted in the initiation of an internal investigation however the results of it are unknown it's strange to see cops taking simple things way too far if you enjoyed the video make sure to like And subscribe for more goodbye