Just after 3 in the morning near Penn Yan, New York, deputies respond to a domestic dispute, and the police bodycam captures two people telling two completely different stories. He says she came at him and smashed a lamp in his face. She says he shoved her into the furniture, pinned her down, and held both hands over her mouth until she could not breathe. One of them has marks on them. The other keeps talking about who pays the rent. This is the full police bodycam breakdown of that call. You hear each account the way the deputies heard it, and you watch one deputy check her injuries before anyone looks at the broken lamp. New York does not let officers arrest whoever called or whoever is loudest. They have to decide who the primary aggressor was, and that comes down to what they can actually prove tonight. Both of them blamed the other. Only one of them had injuries to show for it. We will let you decide whether that was enough. If you or someone you know is living with domestic abuse, the National Domestic Violence Hotline is open 24/7 at 1-800-799-7233. You can also text START to 88788. It is free and confidential. CHAPTERS: 0:00 A 3 AM domestic call 0:52 Her lip, and what she says he did 7:38 Deputies pull the boyfriend aside 9:14 His side of the story 14:05 Two stories that don't line up 20:22 What she asks the deputies for 24:14 The history those old reports missed A quick note before the comments fill up. Nothing in this video is a verdict. These are allegations and an active police investigation, and every person shown is presumed innocent unless a court rules otherwise. We break these down to show how officers work a domestic call and the law behind every choice they make. Footage was obtained through a public records request. #bodycam #policebodycam #domesticdispute

police bodycam arrest law enforcement true crime true crime cases bodycam bodycam footage police body cam domestic dispute domestic dispute bodycam domestic call police bodycam breakdown bodycam breakdown police footage real police footage cops called domestic violence deputies respond police investigation primary aggressor order of protection New York police bodycam police response obstruction of breathing he said she said body cam police